Do you agree with my GOTY pick or do you think another game deserves it more?

KCD 2 is an amazing game, so my GOTY vote goes to it

I love KCD2 believe me I played it a lot it's fantastic, but 33 is still getting my vote.

Even tho kcd 2 is Briliant game. I still stand on Expedition side. For me its 33/10 without a doubt its exacly what i needed. Fresh new fantastic artistic world with interesting characters with their own motivation. The characters feels not artificial. On top with the graphic and ThIS MUSIC gosh and things they do to adapt music tempo/changing themes to match current situation not something you see often. Pair it with satisfying battle at least on expert. It IS innovative fighting system some says its not cause QTE was for example in mario but its bs. The feeling, the idea the art style, the audio everything here was executed perfectly and combination of that is what makes it unique. Many moments from game will stay with me for long. I was engaged for whole time. maxed 3 times :D KDC for me is kinda too boring/normal but i see the vision and its looks Great cant say no. Will play it someday for sure. And i know it will be pleasent suprize. Cheers is anyone leasted until the end :D

All three games look fun to be honest, I haven't played any of them but I am afraid that if I start playing them I will loose track of time and catch myself at 4 in the morning playing games when I should be sleeping because the next day I have to go to work . Really creative with the dentist the developer was there

The issue with just goty is fps players love fps, arpg, mmo, ect are all separate, is it based on quality, content, new innovations or price, subjective and being goty does not guarantee that someone will absolutely love the game.

based

I agree with your conclusion, but KCD2 was really ruined for me by broken cheese that trivialized all the difficulty. Bane poison one-shots all enemies with a single arrow. And you can get rich quickly and easily by going into stores at night and stealing their entire inventories. Easy riches and easy combat really took the excitement out of what would have been a magical experience otherwise.

I played Exp33 and i still don't understand why people think it's such a great story. It's a movie game with dozens of mystery boxes that i guess people liked the reveal of. The music is really the only thing i can praise for it. And what i can't get over how little player choice and exploration is in that game.

Of course kcd II that is not an arguable topic.

While kcd2 was an amazing game expedition 33 wins on story and music front.

xd nah